
Last Sunday, due to circumstances outside my control, I ended up at Toa Payoh Central. And after that, to get home, I decided to go to the the bus stop at Toa Payoh Lorong 6 just outside the supermarket, where I had a choice of buses I could take - the 28 or 59, both taking me home, but using different routes. (Actually, there is the 506 as well, but since it is way more expensive, I didn't even consider using it.) I kinda knew the 59 was the fastest way, but I waited almost 20 minutes with no sign of a bus. Then when the 28 came up, I got tired of waiting and just got on. This 28 was a single decker, unlike the double deckers I usually see during peak hours. (And believe me, there is a need for them - once I could barely squeeze onto one while getting on along New Upper Changi Road). But since it was a Sunday afternoon and nobody was likely to be out it was justified. It was a pleasant ride, going past nice quiet houses along Braddell and Bartley and passing the Geylang Serai market and Bedok Central. And it wasn't crowded - I got my own seat almost the whole way. (On an unrelated note - Why is the new Bartley MRT station in the middle of nowhere? Seriously, the station entrance is a chunk of glass and metal in front of a wooded hill. The only sign of life nearby is the school opposite. The reason they need a station in such a deserted area is, again, beyond me.) But it is not a good idea to read on a bus - I got bored halfway and started reading, only to develop a headache approximately 7 stops later. On disembarkation, I thought, okay, this was not as bad as I had expected. But I still wanted to find out how it compared to the 59.
So, just now, I found myself in Toa Payoh again. Yeah, I have no life, so instead of going home from Orchard by the conventional way (i.e. being like a sardine riding on the East-West line), I decided to take the train up to Toa Payoh and then take a bus from there. It would be better than taking yet another eastbound journey on the MRT which I must have done about a hundred times since I came to Singapore. And at least I would get a seat instead of standing and suffocating the whole way. (To be fair, on the Green line, the only really squishy part is between City Hall and Bugis. After that, from Bugis to Aljunied, you can start to breathe, but you have to be careful turning about in case you elbow anyone. It is only after Aljunied, then you can move about. You can only ever think of getting a seat after Bedok, which is the stop I usually get off from, and thereby I almost always end up standing on the MRT.) So this is how I ended up at the same bus stop as I was six days ago. Fortunately, this time, the 59 bus only took 7 minutes to arrive; I only waited from 6:26pm to 6:33. The bus was quite full, so I had to make do with the backward facing seat, which I usually try to avoid unless I have no choice. But this journey was relatively quick, zipping down the highway back to the east. And I almost didn't notice my stop; I must have zoned out from all the traveling backwards feeling. Anyways, here is a comparison:
Journey Time
28 ~ 57 mins (12:41pm to 1:38pm)
59 ~28 mins (6:33pm to 7:01pm)
(The journey on the 59 took less than half the time than that on the 28.)
Fare
28 ~ $1.33
59 ~ $1.33
(At least SBS is fair in that traveling the same distance gets you the same fare.)
Conclusion: When choosing buses, always pick the one that can take you to your destination faster, if the fare is the same. Because you have better things to do with your life than spending an additional 29 minutes in a bus. You can't even read, and to listen to music you have to pump the volume way up, damaging your ears. The only way the 28 wins in this contest is in cost per minute - it is $0.023 for the 28 compared to $0.0475 on the 59 - but I would argue that maybe, for buses, it is better to have a lower cost per minute than a higher one.